June 1, 2011

Blue Ribbon Pie Contest

We held our 3rd annual Memorial Day picnic at our house this past weekend. I decided to include a Blue Ribbon Pie contest at the picnic as well. I have been wanting to do this for years and finally got the notion to just go for it. We had a turn out of 5 pies which included mine. Here's a list of the pies in the contest.

Oreo Creme

Caramel Apple

Double Bottom Blueberry Lemon and Pecan

Strawberry Rhubarb

Banana Creme

I picked 5 random judges....lucky them!!

We numbered the pies 1 through 5, and each judge was given a small sampling of each delicious pie...one at a time...to taste, savour, and judge. When the tasting was done, each judge cast a secret ballot. The ballots were read as they came out of the bag.....and so a winner was declared!

How can I humbly say it...but, I actually won the Blue Ribbon with my caramel apple pie.

It was funny because, it was my house, my contest, I handmade the ribbon, and then...I won first place. As I put on the ribbon I jokingly said, "I feel like I fixed this thing." But really, it was fair. It was up to the judges, and they could have voted any way they wanted to.

After the contest was over, the pies were open to everyone to taste. I think pretty much everyone who tasted them had a sampling of each...I know I did!

Each pie was so good...they all deserved a ribbon! I mean, it's pie...how can you go wrong!

I am so glad we had the contest! It all played out very well. There seemed to be a lot of interest and a lot of laughs. I definitely plan to do this again next year. I hope that this year's contest has generated a lot of interest for next year, and that we will see new contestants next time!

Click here for all of the recipes for each of these wonderfully delicious pies!


  1. What a neat idea - and congrats to you for winning. All those pies look sooo yummy. Lucky judges!

  2. What a great idea! And congrats on your win. I'm sure you deserved it. Wish I had been there to enter my pie. Maybe next year I'll just show up on your doorstep -- pie in hand.

  3. What a pleasant surprise to see my pie and its recipe posted!

  4. I LOVE it! What a great idea. I also love that you posted the recipes. I have wanted to try caramel apple for a long time. Congratulations on winning.

  5. What a fun idea!! I'm glad it worked out great!! And a fabulous ending to a great BBQ meal!! Can't wait to check out the recipes!

  6. Congratulation Bonnie! I would have loved to be a taste tester!!

  7. Wow! What fun you all must of had. I wish I was there. I can't believe I wasn't asked to judge! What a horrible job! Ha Ha! I wouldn't feel bad about winning. Your pie was the best I'm sure. Thanks for sharing the recipes!

  8. Thank you for sharing your recipes with us! That pie of yours sure looks like a winner :)